By Gayl Mileszko
Market Commentary
Crunching the Numbers
Some investors still view the $4 trillion tax-exempt bond market as a sleepy backwater: dull, staid, opaque, illiquid, uneventful. But a significant number find it to be a complex, innovative, and consequential asset class worth more than a second look because it finances things that Americans actually use. This is not a class with abstract balance sheets teasing that it can revolutionize global industries. Some of its brightest students – bond analysts – are mostly rational thinkers with their feet on the ground rather than dancing in the clouds. Since they represent diverse employers — asset managers and funds, broker-dealers, banks, insurers, rating agencies, financial advisers, or independent research shops — it is rare that they all gather in their respective regions or by their fields of focus to share their insights and outlooks. It is even more rare for a subset of the country’s top analysts, those specializing in high yield munis, to meet. But, this week in Connecticut, just such a group assembled to share experiences and discuss market conditions, emerging partnerships, new financing methods, thorny situations, and intriguing opportunities.
Gathering of the Minds
The annual High Yield Municipal Bond conference hosted by Smith’s Research & Gradings attracts a wide range of strategists, traders, buyers, sellers, raters, bankers, lawyers, trustees, consultants, and advisors. This is the 23rd such gathering of these public finance trendspotters and problem solvers. Their target environment this year once again was a rich one. It includes not just the headliners in distress such as tobacco, Puerto Rico, and private rail, but evolving credit considerations impacting everything from charter schools and higher education to senior living and acute care, affordable housing, and spaceports. As in the past decade or so, some of the hottest topics included artificial intelligence and demographics. A brief summary of the themes and discussion follows.
Demographics Are Not Destiny
The assumption has long been that our population will keep growing but that is no longer the case. Of course, there are areas such as Boise and Park Slope where baby booms are underway. Micro demographics matter. But in general, a larger cohort of older citizens is being supported by a smaller number of younger ones who have more liberal political leanings and much less respect for core U.S. institutions. This has implications for everything from the tax base to housing stock, school facilities, labor markets and construction costs, demand for health care, and wealth management. Good governance and technology can provide some solutions here. But we know that the competition for human capital will be intense, and the K-shaped economy is bound to reflect increasing bifurcation.
As America continues to gray, analysts will be looking for new senior living projects in attractive areas with significant barriers to entry. In higher education, many schools have been successful with remote learning programs; analysts also believe it makes sense for investors to place their primary focus on state universities, including their student housing projects. There will always be demand for housing, but in some areas, it may decline as elders move in droves from their homes into senior communities. In construction, whether for schools or apartments, analysts are looking at flexibility: are walls moveable, can student housing be adapted for workforce housing, is there a reuse for parking garages when many new transportation options become available?
Artificial Intelligence
Analysts agree that AI is a transformational technology, rapidly changing the way we think about disclosure but not necessarily leading to “group think.” It has clearly been a wake-up call for many borrowers to learn how their reporting is being captured, summarized, and evaluated. It is hard to keep up with the developments week by week. Many find that there are far fewer hallucinations than seen 3 to 6 months ago. and we know that cyber risk is massive, particularly for unsophisticated issuers with few security measures in place. All recognize that we have just begun to scratch the surface on agentic adoption, but we know that the element of human judgement will always be essential. AI is being used across the board by bankers and sales executives who find that it actually leads to demand for more face-to-face meetings and conversations. Retail investors find it useful in structuring customized portfolios. Traders use it in relative value exercises and believe that it is in large part responsible for the recent reductions in bid-ask spreads. Despite the recent market conditions being among the worst since 1982, they have been able to download bid lists into AI to be scrubbed for unusual value, and this has helped to keep this $4.4 trillion market liquid. Operations professionals find that it helps to prevent many mistakes.
Analysts as a whole are happier and more productive than ever as they have reduced time spent on data entry and can truly focus on their credit evaluations. They like to use one version like Claude to critique Chat GPT and vice versa. Some ignore ratings and labels altogether and place their focus on behavioral patterns One portfolio manager has been downloading disclosure filings and rating reports on every outstanding CUSIP and believes the project will be completed by this year end. Of course, everyone remains a bit skeptical and continues to test AI for known truths. Some strategists find that it helps to separate the noise from true signals and forecast weak, neutral, and strong market conditions. One reported that AI has been 25% accurate in predicting spread movements 30 days out; that number increased to 50% 60 days out and 65% 90 days out. The consensus, perhaps overly optimistic, is that AI is not expected to lead to massive job displacement but will continue to be a force multiplier.
Investing in the Future: Spaceports as the New Frontier
Bond analysts are taking a look at a whole new innovative sector coming to the muni market: private activity bonds for spaceports made possible by the One Big Beautiful bill. The legislation treats spaceports rather like airports, allowing governmental issuers to use tax-exempt bonds, not subject to state caps, to finance qualifying launch, flight control assembly, and related manufacturing facilities as long as they are in close proximity to a launch or re-entry site and are owned by a governmental entity. This means that a private aerospace/spaceport project can potentially be financed using tax-exempt PABs, rather than the space company simply issuing its own higher yielding taxable corporate bonds. Facility users will be government agencies, commercial space companies, defense contractors, and satellite operators — those that launch rockets and spacecraft. It is entirely possible that the entire Not-In-My-Backyard Brouhaha underway will fade as soon as data centers can be launched into space and positioned to maximize use of solar power.
Bond investors will thoroughly dissect the first few muni spaceport bond financings and set some important new standards in terms for the deals to follow. It will be critical for investors to understand the siting, revenue source, obligor, and tenants, the contracts, payment features, licensing, lease structure, guarantees, construction, and technology risk. The useful life of the facilities would only be about 5 to 7 years. There will initially be no mature balance sheets or standard formats to review, but the sponsorships will likely be strong, coming from companies with thousands of employees and billions in revenue who have funded the development to this point. Demand is expected to be heavy given the mixed commercial and national defense nature of these projects.
Hospitals and Healthcare
We are all consumers of health care and have strong feelings about our community hospital, so there is a personal aspect to how we look at hospital credits. We are receiving most care on an outpatient basis, so it comes as no surprise that those patients in the hospital today are far sicker than they have ever been. Analysts currently peg 20% of hospitals as well positioned for growth but 15% of existing hospitals are troubled. The rest fall somewhere in between. Hospital administrators all struggle with pressures on revenue, cash and liquidity, pharmaceutical price inflation, collections, a shortage of radiologists, and insurance rejections. But the greatest concern is with the 208,000 shortfall in nurses about to hit in the next two years as the need for bedside care becomes even more critical. Most have taken defensive actions, some have cut everything but core services and many have explored sales or affiliations, Merger and acquisition activity is picking up but it is mainly concentrated among the stronger systems. Knowing that every number in every hospital has a story behind it, and that we live in an era of heightened regulatory and legislative risk, analysts rely heavily upon leadership to clearly articulate their efforts, plans, and innovative approaches to meeting challenges. Frequent, timely, and comprehensive updates are sought so that there are no surprises as exposure to funding cuts at the federal and state levels intensifies.
Puerto Rico
Analysts agree that there is an unquestionable need for good investor relations if Puerto Rico is ever going to rid themselves of PROMESA, now in its 10th year, and regain market access. While there are many well-intentioned people at work on solutions, and there are encouraging signs in the form of a balanced budget, efforts on permitting reform, pharmaceutical companies expanding their manufacturing presence, and San Juan’s recently successful refunding and new money sale, some ugly facts cannot be ignored. The PREPA bankruptcy has yet to be resolved. The budget has increased by 40% in 10 years. There have been no fiscal reforms enacted and very little has been done to cut expenses. There is still no capacity for capex, and the pay-as-you-go pension payment framework is unsustainable. Washington is clearly apathetic while recoveries after the next storms hinge almost entirely on FEMA support. Law firms are earning staggering fees but accomplishing …… nothing. And analysts find it hard to get comfortable with bondholder security when a general obligation priority lien can be eliminated with the stroke of a pen.
Special District Finance
Several states have recently passed new laws creating special districts to finance development infrastructure. Oklahoma now has master development districts. Tennessee has authorized infrastructure development districts. And Arizona has created state affordability infrastructure districts. These new entities lie somewhere between traditional municipal special assessment districts and land-secured high yield municipal finance. When presented with investment opportunities, it is important to learn details on developer equity, lien priorities, who controls the district, who owns the land at bond issuance, what the specific enforcement mechanics are, and whether debt is district-only or has any governmental backing.
Charter School: Stronger Metrics but Impairments as Up
Some analysts are wary of investing in the charter school space, given that birth rates have fallen, competition has increased with so many new school choice options, and construction costs are rising. In addition, some schools have key man risk about to become evident as founders and principals, the keepers of the vision, retire. Many schools do not track and report on retention rates and fail to accurately project fall enrollment. On top of that, 8% of outstanding bonds are impaired or in default. Charter school enrollment has actually dropped for the first time ever in some areas due to immigration policies, demographic moves, population declines, loss of the inspirational leader, and the introduction of vouchers. There is no doubt that pressures faced by standalones as well as systems are significant, but investors can find creditworthy schools, ones with strong leaders at the board and executive levels with entrepreneurial skills, willing to adapt to all the changes underway, and committed to maintaining good investor relations. This means clear transparency in the form of consistent, useful, timely financial and operational disclosures on EMMA, calls with bondholders, and rapid event reporting.
Given all the changes in education likely to occur during the next 40 years, analysts are taking a close look at school construction plans; they question whether the walls are moveable in order to adjust classroom size, and if the buildings themselves can be retrofitted for other use. They are weeding out the weak credits – those with leaders inexperienced on the business side, the schools with high senior management turnover or founders about to exit without a clear succession plan, those taking on too much additional debt, and those publishing inconsistent reports that are hard to read, come infrequently, get filed late, and fail to provide the metrics and narrative needed to understand the true status of the school. Investors understand that the needs of students and expectations of parents in urban and rural areas can be markedly different with regard to security, transportation, athletics, after-school programs, and wraparound social services. But they find that distress comes when management cannot adapt to changes, adjust to reality and rework strategy, or demonstrate the discipline and systems needed to identify and prepare for the next set of structural, demographic, technology, or funding related challenges.
What Comes Next in Senior Living and Care?
After years of peaks and troughs, senior living is now seeing the crest of the so-called Silver Tsunami with the first Baby Boomers turning 80 and a big wave expected through 2040. Although the industry is still dealing with the lingering effects of COVID, occupancy is back to pre-pandemic highs, but new construction has slowed, and existing properties have aged and need improvements. The level of interest in investing in this sector is outrunning all other real estate sectors. But the original concept of life plan communities has evolved such that not all offer the full continuum anymore. Many now focus on the higher margin independent living units and have eliminated skilled nursing, admitting that they cannot provide expensive health care for residents as for-profit providers can, and shifting some of their services to assisted living and home care. The number of nursing homes has been decreasing since the mid-90s, placing new burdens on the ones in operation; 57% now have a waiting list. Health care “deserts” now exist in many rural parts of the country. With respect to assisted living, there has been an uptick in tax-credit deals in states like Indiana, Ohio, Illinois, and Minnesota. Some developers are laser focused on the middle market. High end rental senior living developers have established partnerships enabling them to obtain lower financing rates in the tax-exempt bond market. Several of these projects will be coming online in the next 12-18 months, and investors will be looking for proof of concept. Has the operator leased up as expected, are they providing the suite of services promised and generating the expected returns?
Rates, Structures, and Returns
Borrowers obviously look for the lowest possible rates and borrowing costs. Some explore the use of 8- to 10-year bullets. These structures do present refinancing risk and often only appeal to certain buyers. The use of this kind of structure requires borrowers to make projections on future liquidity positions and the ability to access the capital markets that sometimes end up being too rosy; enrollment, occupancy, users, admissions, and fees may just not pan out as planned. On the other hand, the timing can work perfectly. In any event, heavy focus is placed on conditions prevailing as the bullet year draws nearer. As in the case of bond anticipation notes soon coming due, analysts will take a fresh look at the strength of the management team, how successful the borrower has been in previous budgeting and forecasting, their financial flexibility, cash positions, and endowment. New stress tests and sensitivity analyses are often run, and new focus is placed on the location and sponsor, construction costs and completion, the demand and rate environment, competition, taxes, maintenance costs, and net operating income margin expectations.
Market Conditions: Favorable Pricing for The View at Goodwin Living
While high yield analysts met this week in Greenwich, the bond market has rallied again. For the second week in a row, yields have fallen. At this writing, the 2-year Treasury yield at 4.63% is down 15 basis points, the 10-year at 4.95% has dropped 28 basis points, and the 30-year at 5.28% is 31 basis points lower. In the past two weeks, the 2-year AAA municipal general obligation benchmark at 2.81% has fallen 49 basis points, the 10-year at 3.60% is down 38 basis points, and the 30-year at 4.89% is 23 basis points lower. HJ Sims was able to take advantage of favorable conditions to bring a $305,310,000 financing to market for The View at Goodwin Living. The non-rated bonds were issued through the Alexandria, Virginia Industrial Development Authority and were structured with a 2061 final maturity that priced with a coupon of 6.50% to yield 6.75%. Please reach out to your HJ Sims representative for more information on this transaction as well as on our forward calendar.